The SAFE-Trial: Awake Craniotomy Versus Surgery Under General Anesthesia for Glioblastoma Patients.
Keywords
Abstract
Description
Rationale Glioblastoma Multiforme (GBM) or Astrocytoma's grade IV (WHO) are devastating tumors with one of the worst prognoses in oncology. Extending resection improves survival in patients with GBM. Surgery of GBM nowadays is usually performed under general anesthesia (GA) and resections are not as aggressive as possible, due to the chance of seriously damaging the patient with a rather low life expectancy. A surgical technique optimizing resection of the tumor in eloquent areas but preventing neurological deficits is necessary to improve survival and quality of life in these patients. Awake craniotomy (AC) with the use of cortical and subcortical stimulation is an alternative surgical technique that is standardly implemented in surgery for low grade glioma, but not yet for GBM. AC has shown to increase resection percentage and preserve quality of life in low grade glioma (LGG) and could be of important value in the surgery of GBM.
Objective The study is performed to increase safety and efficacy during surgery in patients with GBM in eloquent areas. This study will compare awake craniotomy with surgery under general anesthesia for patients with GBM near or in eloquent areas. Primary end points are: 1) Proportion of patients with NIH Stroke Scale (NIHSS) deterioration at 6 weeks post- surgery, where deterioration is defined as at least one point increase in total NIHSS score compared to baseline. 2) Proportion of patients without residual contrast-enhancing tumour on postoperative MRI. Secondary end points are: 1) Health related quality of life (HRQoL) at 6 weeks, 3 months and 6 months after operation. 2) Progression-free survival (PFS) at 12 months after operation. 3) Overall survival (OS) at 12 months after operation. 4) Frequency and severity of Serious Adverse Effects in each group: Infections, intracranial bleeding, epilepsy, aphasia, paresis/paralysis in arms or/and legs. Also, a cost benefit analysis will be performed.
Study design The trial is set up as a multicenter randomized controlled study. The study will include 246 patients in 5 neurosurgical centers in the Netherlands. Patients with GBM in eloquent areas on diagnostic MRI will be selected by the neurosurgeons according to the eligibility criteria. After informed consent the patient will be randomized for awake craniotomy (AC) or regular craniotomy under general anesthesia (GA) with 1:1 allocation ratio. After surgery, only patients with histologically proven GBM will continue with the study. Patients in whom no GBM could not be proven histologically, will be considered off-study. Thereafter, patients will receive the standard treatment with concomitant Temozolomide and radiation therapy and standard follow up. Total duration of the study is 5 years. Patient inclusion is 4 years. Follow-up is 1 year.
Study population Patients aged 18-90 years old, with Glioblastoma Multiforme near or in eloquent areas and eligible for awake craniotomy.
Intervention Awake craniotomy compared to craniotomy under general anaesthesia
Main study parameters/endpoints
1. Proportion of patients with NIHSS deterioration at 6 weeks post-surgery
2. Proportion of patients without residual contrast-enhancing tumour on postoperative MRI
Nature and extent of the burden and risks associated with participation, benefit and group relatedness Patients have 50% chance to be randomized for an awake procedure. The risk-benefit-ratio of this procedure in patients with GBM is subject of this trial and the investigators expect less neurological morbidity than surgery under generalised anaesthesia. Three quality of life questionnaires and 1 neurological examination will take place preoperatively, 6 weeks after, 3 months after and 6 months after the surgery. The burden of this trial for the patient is therefore confined.
Dates
| Last Verified: | 02/28/2019 |
| First Submitted: | 02/27/2019 |
| Estimated Enrollment Submitted: | 02/28/2019 |
| First Posted: | 03/03/2019 |
| Last Update Submitted: | 02/28/2019 |
| Last Update Posted: | 03/03/2019 |
| Actual Study Start Date: | 02/27/2019 |
| Estimated Primary Completion Date: | 03/05/2023 |
| Estimated Study Completion Date: | 03/03/2024 |
Condition or disease
Intervention/treatment
Procedure: Awake craniotomy
Procedure: Craniotomy under general anesthesia
Phase
Arm Groups
| Arm | Intervention/treatment |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Awake craniotomy Cortical stimulation is performed with a bipolar electrical stimulator. The Boston naming test and repetition of words is done in cooperation with a neuropsychologist/linguist, who will inform the neurosurgeon of any kind of speech arrest or dysarthria. When localizing the motor and sensory cortex, the patient is asked to report any unintended movement or sensation in extremities or face. Functional cortical areas are marked with a number. When the tumour margins or white matter is encountered or when on regular neuronavigation the eloquent white matter tracts are thought to be in close proximity, subcortical stimulation (biphasic currents of 8-16 mA, pulse frequency 60 Hz, single pulse phase duration of 100 microsec., 2-second train) is performed to localize functional tracts. | Procedure: Awake craniotomy Awake craniotomy |
| Active Comparator: Craniotomy under general anesthesia Trephination and tumour resection are performed without any additional neuro-psychological monitoring or brain mapping, guided by STEALTH-neuronavigation. | Procedure: Craniotomy under general anesthesia Craniotomy under general anesthesia |
Eligibility Criteria
| Ages Eligible for Study | 18 Years To 18 Years |
| Sexes Eligible for Study | All |
| Accepts Healthy Volunteers | Yes |
| Criteria | Inclusion Criteria: 1. Age ≥18 years and ≤ 90 years 2. Tumor diagnosed as Glioblastoma Multiforme on MRI with distinct ring-like pattern of contrast enhancement with thick irregular walls and a core area reduced signal suggestive of tumour necrosis as assessed by the surgeon 3. Tumors situated in or near eloquent areas; motor cortex, sensory cortex, subcortical pyramidal tract or speech areas as indicated on MRI (Sawaya Grading II and II) 4. The tumor is suitable for resection (according to neurosurgeon) 5. Karnofsky performance scale 80 or more 6. Written Informed consent Exclusion Criteria: 1. Tumors of the cerebellum, brain stem or midline 2. Multifocal contrast enhancing lesions 3. Substantial non-contrast enhancing tumor areas suggesting low grade gliomas with malignant transformation 4. Medical reasons precluding MRI (eg, pacemaker) 5. Inability to give consent because of or language barrier 6. Psychiatric history 7. Previous brain tumour surgery 8. Previous low-grade glioma. 9. Second primary malignancy within the past 5 years with the exception of adequately treated in situ carcinoma of any organ or basal cell carcinoma of the skin. 10. Severe aphasia or dysphasia |
Outcome
Primary Outcome Measures
1. Postoperative neurological morbidity [Between operation and 6 weeks postoperatively]
2. Proportion of gross-total resections [Assessed on 48 hours postoperative scan]
Secondary Outcome Measures
1. Health-related quality of life assessed by EQ-5D questionnaire [Between baseline and 6 weeks/3 months/6 months postoperatively]
2. Health-related quality of life assessed by EORTC-QLQ-BN20 questionnaire [Between baseline and 6 weeks/3 months/6 months postoperatively]
3. Health-related quality of life assessed by EORTC-QLQ-C30 questionnaire [Between baseline and 6 weeks/3 months/6 months postoperatively]
4. Progression-free survival [Between surgery and 12 months postoperatively]
5. Overall survival [Between surgery and 12 months postoperatively]
6. Postoperative (serious) adverse events [Between surgery and 6 weeks postoperatively]
