Prospective Trial Comparing Intravesical Chondroitin Sulphate 2% and DMSO in the Treatment of PBS/Interstitial Cystitis
Mots clés
Abstrait
La description
A. Introduction
Painful bladder syndrome(PBS) is a syndrome which is poorly understood. Patients usually report suprapubic pain related to bladder filling and also report urinary urgency and frequency. In a subgroup of patients, typical cystoscopic findings can be noted and this defines this subgroup as interstitial cystitis. (Abrams et al. 116-26) The treatment of PBS/IC is empirical. Bladder hydrodistension under anesthesia, tricyclic antidepressants, antihistaminics and intravesical DMSO instillations are the only treatment for which some evidence exists in the literature. More than 150 other treatment modalities have been described . Most of them were poorly studied. (Fall et al. 1-99) Intravesical treatment with DMSO has stood the test of time and is the only FDA approved intravesical treatment of PBS/IC. DMSO however is also used as a solvent in the chemical industry and is in fact used ' off label' in this indication. (Erickson 333-43;Emerson and Perezmarrero A136;Perez-Marrero, Emerson, and Feltis 36-39) One of the theories on which intravesical treatment is based, claims that the glycosaminoglycan layer, which protects the urothelial cells is damaged. DMSO, Chondroitin sulphate, hyaluronic acid and heparin have been used to repair the GAG layer with variable clinical success. (Daha et al. 369-72;Daha et al. 987-90;Riedl et al. 717-21) Chondroitin sulphate seems to be promising, but comparative data are lacking. (Gauruder-Burmester and Popken 355-59;Nickel et al. 56-60;Hauser et al. 2477-82;Nordling and van Ophoven 328-35) Assessing the outcome of such treatments is difficult. Objective parameters such as daytime and nighttime frequency may not always reflect the impact of the condition on the life of the patient.
Patient reported outcome parameters are more frequently used to assess treatments in overactive bladder disease and in painful bladder research. Several validated questionnaires can be used to assess patients with PBS/IC. One of the most frequently used is the O'Leary-Sant questionnaire ( see annex 1). Next to this questionnaire the Global Response Assessment will be used. This is a validated 7 point Likert scale comparing the current status of the patient to the pre-intervention status. This scale has been used in several other studies on PBS/IC. (Nickel et al. 910-18;Baranowski et al. 33-36) Aim To compare the clinical effectiveness of intravesical chondroitin sulphate 2% ( Uracyst ™) and DMSO 50% in the treatment of patients with painful bladder syndrome
B. Randomization A central randomization will be used. Participating centers will have to contact the trial office of the dept. of urology of the University Hospitals Leuven to randomize the patient to one or the other treatment, either by telephone 016/346692 or 016/348345 or by mail elza.goossens@uzleuven.be or evelien.vankriekingen@uzleuven.be . A block randomization per center will be done. The randomization list was generated on a web application ( www.randomizer.org) to ensure an unbiased randomization schedule.
C. Protocol of administration Patients that are enrolled in the study will receive one intravesical instillation of Uracyst or DMSO a week during 6 weeks. DMSO is prepared as a 50% solution in 50cc physiologic serum. Uracyst will be prepared by the nurse or urologist administering the product.
Uracyst is delivered as a 2% sterile solution in 20cc vials. The instillation is done by a urethral catheterization. The catheter is withdrawn once the fluid has been instilled. The solution is kept in the bladder for at least 30 minutes. A simple instillation protocol is followed, meaning that the patient can move immediately after the instillation of the product. The product is eliminated by spontaneous voiding after 30 minutes.
D. Safety Safety is assessed by monitoring adverse events at every visit. Anticipated adverse events are hematuria, algiuria, urinary tract infection and garlic odor ( for DMSO)…
E. Statistics Comparison of the mean GRA by T-test will be used for the primary endpoint. Appropriate statistical tests will be used for the secondary variables.
To detect a 0.75 difference on the 7 point Likert scale, with 80% power at 0.05% significance 45 patients will be needed in each group.
Rendez-vous
| Dernière vérification: | 01/31/2020 |
| Première soumission: | 03/30/2013 |
| Inscription estimée soumise: | 02/10/2020 |
| Première publication: | 02/12/2020 |
| Dernière mise à jour soumise: | 02/10/2020 |
| Dernière mise à jour publiée: | 02/12/2020 |
| Date de début réelle de l'étude: | 02/28/2010 |
| Date d'achèvement primaire estimée: | 08/31/2013 |
| Date estimée d'achèvement de l'étude: | 12/30/2013 |
Condition ou maladie
Intervention / traitement
Procedure: Bladder instillations
Phase
Groupes d'armes
| Bras | Intervention / traitement |
|---|---|
| Experimental: Chondroitin sulphate 2% chondoritin sulphate 2% ( Uracyst) for bladder instillation. One bladeer instillation per week during 6 weeks. | |
| Active Comparator: DMSO 50% DMSO 50% in saline for bladder instillation. One bladder instillation per week during 6 weeks |
Critère d'éligibilité
| Âges éligibles aux études | 18 Years À 18 Years |
| Sexes éligibles à l'étude | All |
| Accepte les bénévoles en santé | Oui |
| Critères | Inclusion Criteria: 1. Female and male patients from 18-75 years 2. A history of symptoms of bladder pain/discomfort described as suprapubic pain related to bladder filling, accompanied by other symptoms such as daytime and/or nighttime frequency in the absence of infection or other pathology, with or without the typical cystoscopic findings of interstitial cystitis 3. Patients willing and able to complete the necessary questionnaires Exclusion Criteria: 1. Patients with transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder or other significant malignancy 2. Pregnant women 3. Breastfeading women 4. Patients with significant bacteriuria 5. Patients with hematuria 6. Neurogenic bladder 7. Patients with indwelling catheters 8. Chronic bacterial prostatitis 9. Currently receiving or having received investigational drugs thirty (30) days or less prior to screening 10. Currently receiving or having had prior therapy with intravesical treatment (eg. Uracyst, Cystistat®, heparin or BCG) 11. Receiving therapy for less than three months with antidepressants, antihistaminics, hormonal agonists or antagonists; hence patient not stabilized on therapy. (Stable therapy defined as continuous treatment for at least three months.) 12. IC symptoms relieved by antimicrobials, anticholinergics or antispasmodics 13. Functional Bladder capacity of greater than 400 ml 14. Neurologic disease affecting bladder function; any previous surgery or procedure having affected bladder function 15. Current diagnosis of chemical, tuberculous or radiation cystitis 16. bladder or lower ureteral calculi 17. History of cancer within the last five years other than adequately treated non-melanoma skin cancers 18. Active sexual transmitted disease 19. Current vaginitis 20. Endometriosis 21. Any condition/disease which in the opinion of the investigator could interfere with patient compliance and/ or interfere with the interpretation of the treatment results |
Résultat
Mesures des résultats primaires
1. Global response assessment scale [4 weeks after last treatment]
Mesures des résultats secondaires
1. Urinary Frequency [4 weeks after last treatment]
2. Nocturia Episodes [4 weeks after last treatment]
3. Functional bladder capacity [4 weeks after last treatment]
4. VAS pain scale [4 weeks after last treatment]
5. O'Leary Sant [4 weeks after last treatment]
Autres mesures des résultats
1. Drop-out [any time during study]
